Summary
Our client was the manager of a pharmacy when an incident of theft occurred. In an attempt to stop the shoplifter, a bystander was injured as a result of our client’s actions. Our client was subsequently placed under investigation by the police for grievous bodily harm. After Partner Andy Hobdell expertly engaged in pre-charge representations with the police, the matter ultimately resulted in no further action.
Details of the Incident
While working as a pharmacy store manager, an incident of theft occurred in which our client and other colleagues were threatened by the shoplifter. Our client attempted to pursue the shoplifter to recover any stolen items if they were discarded. In a moment of poor judgement, our client threw a shopping basket at the shoplifter in self-defence.
Unfortunately, the shopping basket missed the shoplifter and instead hit a bystander on the street. As a result of the impact, the bystander fell to the ground and suffered a deep laceration to the head, which required several stitches and left a scar. The severity of the injury was akin to grievous bodily harm (GBH).
GBH is considered an extremely serious offence under UK law. Although our client had no intention of causing the injury, if the matter proceeded to court, he was at risk of receiving a prison sentence of up to 36 weeks.
Our Defence
Our client was immediately remorseful for the harm caused by his actions. When interviewed by the police, our client fully accepted that his actions were wrong but maintained that he never intended to cause any harm to the victim; he only intended to defend himself from the shoplifter.
After initially being represented by a different firm of solicitors, our client instructed Partner Andy Hobdell to engage in pre-charge representations due to Lawtons’ expertise and aptitude in representing high-stakes cases at the police investigation stage.
Andy worked diligently and made extensive representations to the police to highlight the unique circumstances of our client’s situation. Our client had already faced consequences at work, where he had been subject to a disciplinary hearing. His actions were considered a dismissible offence however, due to his long service, good character and remorse, he received a final written warning and was moved to another branch.
In addition, since the incident our client had carried out reflective learning, completed multiple counselling sessions, and provided significant evidence of changed behaviour. These actions were corroborated by extensive character references, all of which were provided to the police.
No Further Action
Thanks to Andy’s expertise and the strength of his representations on our client’s behalf, the police ultimately confirmed that the CPS had refused to authorise a charge and the matter therefore resulted in no further action.
This is a fantastic and extremely favourable outcome for our client, given his personal circumstances and the unusual details of the case. Without Andy’s intervention and guidance, our client may have faced a much more severe outcome.
Client Testimonial
“Exceptional Defence – Andy saved my career and reputation
I cannot recommend Andy highly enough for any professional facing a police or CPS investigation. I instructed Andy in September 2025 at an incredibly stressful time; my case was already heading towards court, and I had completely lost confidence in my previous legal representation.
As a Pharmacist Store Manager, my professional reputation and my livelihood were on the line. Andy immediately took control of the situation. He was proactive, highly strategic, and understood the high stakes for someone in my position. His ability to communicate effectively with the police and the CPS changed the entire trajectory of the investigation.
Thanks to his intervention, a situation that felt destined for a trial ended in a total No Further Action (NFA) result. I am now able to continue my career as a Store Manager with my reputation entirely intact. If you need a solicitor who truly understands the needs of professionals and will fight to protect your future, Andy is the best in the business.”
Looking for specialist pre-charge engagement solicitors?
At Lawtons, we understand that there is no ‘one-size-fits-all’ approach when it comes to criminal defence. For cases requiring pre-charge engagement, we prioritise transparency over fixed fees, ensuring that you receive the highest quality of service.
The actions taken in the earliest moments of a criminal investigation are often the ones with the most profound consequences. Don’t hesitate – get in touch with our team today.
