Summary
Our client was being offered a conditional caution for assault occasioning actual bodily harm (ABH) with financial compensation of £4,500. Consultant Finbarr Cuneen was instructed by our client on a privately funded basis to provide pre-charge advice, and thanks to Finbarr’s expertise, our client was instead offered a conditional caution for affray with no financial compensation.
Details of Case
In August 2026 our client was on a night out with his friends and had consumed seven pints when the complainant was seen attempting to assault members of the public, this escalated into a heated argument after our client pushed him away from the group.
As the complainant began to walk away, our client pushed him in the back on the belief that this would prevent the complainant from harming someone else. However, this caused the complainant to fall face first and sustain injuries, including two knocked out teeth, a broken wrist/arm and bruising to his torso and arm.
Our client was then arrested as a result of this on suspicion of s18 GBH and was promptly interviewed under caution at Clough Road Police Station where he was represented by the duty solicitor.
After making admissions in interview the police made it clear they would be prepared to offer the client a conditional caution for ABH, with the condition being that he pay for the complainant’s dental work to the value of £4,500 compensation.
Our Defence
Our client then instructed consultant Finbarr Cuneen on a privately funded basis to provide urgent pre-charge advice, as he required a specialist view on the police’s offer before deciding.
Finbarr took over from the duty solicitor and went through the case disclosure and police station notes with the client. After reviewing all the evidence Finbarr advised the client that CCTV footage of the incident would not support a self-defence case if it showed a forceful push to the back of the complainant.
Instead, Finbarr utilised his expertise in pre-charge engagement and negotiated with the case officer to change the caution from ABH to affray, as the complainant had subsequently decided he no longer wished to go ahead with his complaint of assault. The clear CCTV and medical evidence alongside the clients’ admissions in police interview amounted to strong evidence of the public order offence of Affray, which did not require the Complainant’s evidence in support for the police to proceed with that alternative offence.
Finbarr advised our client to accept this amended caution, on the basis that there was no credible argument as to him acting in self-defence and that this would not withstand scrutiny if the client was charged by the police and taken to court. If that happened, it would have resulted in a conviction for our client and exposure to a substantial claim for compensation.
Outcome
Our client accepted the revised conditional caution offered by the police, which was now a conditional caution for affray. The financial compensation element of the caution was dropped after the complainant decided he did not want to go ahead with it, instead the condition of the caution was for our client to attend one alcohol advice session.
Having the conditional caution dropped from ABH to affray, and the matter not going to court was a fantastic result for our client. As a result of Finbarr’s expert guidance, he received no charge or conviction, allowing him to put this stressful situation behind him.
This case was a testament to Finbarr’s skill, highlighting the importance of instructing specialists in criminal defence on a privately funded basis in order to receive the most favourable outcome possible for your case.
Looking for specialist pre-charge engagement solicitors?
At Lawtons, we understand that there is no ‘one-size-fits-all’ approach when it comes to criminal defence. For cases requiring pre-charge engagement, we prioritise transparency over fixed fees, ensuring that you receive the highest quality of service.
The actions taken in the earliest moments of a criminal investigation are often the ones with the most profound consequences. Don’t hesitate – get in touch with our team today.
